Wednesday, June 7, 2023

057 - Ukraine and Nordstream Affair

PREFACE/ISSUE
 
This post describes Ukrainian connection to the Nordstream affair.

The Prodigy - Narayan




I. Ukraine & Ukrainian officials talking about the Nordstream 

6 June 2021 - Exclusive: Zelensky "surprised" and "disappointed" by Biden pipeline move

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky says he learned through the press — not any direct heads-up — that President Biden had decided to stop trying to block a Russian pipeline that Ukraine sees as a dire national security threat. 

Driving the news: Zelensky used an hourlong Zoom interview with Axios on Friday to beseech Biden to meet with him face to face before a June 16 summit with Russian President Vladimir Putin — offering to join him "at any moment and at any spot on the planet."

The embattled leader spoke of Putin's psychological pressure campaign; his own anger-turned-disappointment at the U.S.; and his hope that Biden, whom he compares to basketball great Michael Jordan, can still outmaneuver Russia and rescue Ukraine. 

[M: A must read article describing the US - GER - UA views] 

14 June 2021 - Volodymyr Zelensky tells Boris Johnson Nord Stream 2 commissioning by Russia "unacceptable"

President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky says the Nord Stream 2 project is a challenge to Ukraine in the field of security, noting that the commissioning of the new pipeline bypassing Ukraine would be "unacceptable."

During the call, Zelensky raised the issue of counteracting the implementation of the Nord Stream 2 project, which he said is "a security challenge for Ukraine," according to the President's Office.

The president stressed the importance of further cooperation with the United Kingdom in the field of developing Ukraine's defense capabilities and strengthening the Ukrainian fleet. 

[M: UK government official´s statements before summer 2021 are listed here]  

22 August 2021 - Nord Stream 2 'dangerous geopolitical weapon': Zelensky

Kiev sees the soon-to-be completed Nord Stream 2 pipeline carrying Russian gas to Europe and bypassing Ukraine as "a dangerous geopolitical weapon", President Volodymyr Zelensky said Sunday.

The Ukrainian leader was speaking at a joint press conference in Kiev with German Chancellor Angela Merkel, who has spearheaded the pipeline fiercely opposed by Russian neighbours Ukraine, Poland and the Baltic states.

The $12-billion pipeline beneath the Baltic Sea is set to double Russian natural gas shipments to Germany, Europe's largest economy. It avoids Ukraine, depriving Kiev of essential gas transit fees.

[M: Yearly transit fees are around € 2 Billion] 

Merkel said the Germany-US agreement specifies "sanctions" if gas is "used as a weapon". 

23 Sept 2021 - Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Boris Johnson discussed further steps to enhance strategic partnership between Ukraine and Great Britain

The parties discussed cooperation in the field of energy, in particular nuclear energy, and challenges for the European region due to the implementation of the Nord Stream 2 project. The President of Ukraine stressed that this project is a geopolitical weapon of Russia.

12 Nov 2021 - Ukraine publicly pleads with U.S. Senate to sanction Putin's pipeline

"Blackmailing Europe over gas must be stopped forever," Zelensky tweeted on Friday. "We're grateful to the House for including an #NDAA amendment that will stop Nord Stream 2. Asking all friends of and in the US Senate to now back this amendment at the Senate level." 

18 Nov 2021 - Nord Stream 2: Will you go to the Gazprom with me?

British Prime Minister Boris Johnson said on Monday that “a choice is shortly coming” for Europe, between consuming more Russian fossil fuels or sticking up for Ukraine and championing the cause of peace and stability.

[M: Signing of 10 Nov 2022  - U.S.-Ukraine Charter on Strategic Partnership - The USA confirmed that it will help Ukraine to regain control over its East provinces and Crimea and help it to join North Atlantic structures without naming them. Signing of the charter has triggered Russia to move armies toward Ukrainian border. The conflict was inevitable.] 

30 Nov 2021 - Liz Truss urges NATO allies to block Russia’s Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline

It remains to be seen how far the UK can push its opposition to Nord Stream 2 but the prime minister, Boris Johnson, raised the issue’s profile in a foreign policy speech at the Guildhall this month, saying: “We hope that our friends may recognise that a choice is shortly coming between mainlining ever more Russian hydrocarbons in giant new pipelines, and sticking up for Ukraine and championing the cause of peace and stability.”

30 Nov 2021 - Russia will pay the price if it invades Ukraine:

Foreign Secretary LIZ TRUSS underlines her determination to stand up to Vladimir Putin 

8 Dec 2021 - Liz TrussEurope needs to end energy dependency on Russia, says UK foreign minister

British foreign minister Liz Truss said on Wednesday Europe would become increasingly hooked on Russian gas if Moscow got its way and it was time for countries to end that dependency.

The EU (European Union) relies on Russia for over 40% of its gas, and with some countries Russia has a complete monopoly of supply. If Russia gets its way, Europe will be increasingly hooked on its gas,” Truss told the Chatham House think tank.

We have to end this strategic dependency,” she said, adding she would meet her Ukrainian counterpart on Wednesday to strengthen their ties and repeat the message that any Russian incursion into Ukraine would be a mistake.

Germany has agreed to take action if Russia uses energy as a weapon in its relations with Ukraine, but the deal does not provide a specific criteria for how that would be judged. 

11 Dec 2021 - UK seeks unity at G7 meeting over Russia’s ‘malign behaviour’

Getting a unified response from the G-7, a group of countries with disparate interests, has often proved tough. Germany plans on getting gas from Russia soon through the contentious Nord Stream 2 pipeline, which bypasses UkraineBritain, which is not dependent on Russian gas, generally takes a tougher line on the pipeline — but faces tough questions about London’s financial district and property market, both hubs for Russian money.
Truss said she wanted to work with other countries “to make sure that free democratic nations are able to have an alternative to Russian gas supplies.

She met on the sidelines of the gathering with Germany’s new foreign minister, Annalena Baerbock, a politician from the environmentalist Greens who previously opposed Nord Stream 2. 

17 Dec 2021 - Zelensky, Johnson discuss energy security issues, situation in Donbas

Later, the President's Office of Ukraine said on its website that Johnson and Zelensky expressed a common position on the inadmissibility of using the Nord Stream 2 project as a weapon. 

6 Jan 2022 - U.K. Foreign Secretary Liz Truss Announces Kyiv Visit, Says Russia's Only Path Forward Is De-Escalation With Ukraine

Truss said, "and I'm working with allies and partners to highlight the strategic risks of this project."

"Europe must reduce its dependence on Russian gas," Truss added. 

6 February 2022 - British Elite Troops Sent to Ukraine Amid Fears of Russian Invasion

More than 100 members of Britain’s elite special forces have been sent to Ukraine amid fears a Russian invasion is imminent. The specialist forces are believed to be helping train Ukrainian special forces in counter-insurgency tactics, sniping and sabotage

Crack troops from the SAS, the SBS, the Special Reconnaissance Regiment and the Special Forces Support group are understood to be working in the country as military advisers 

British special forces have been able to deploy such a large number to the region as they are no longer operating in Afghanistan.

Although the SAS and SBS are still in Syria and Iraq, the numbers of troops there are believed to be relatively small.

As BBC reported earlier, the SAS and other UK Special Forces (UKSF) were poised to receive a new mission countering Russian and other forces around the world.

The plan was called 'Special Operations Concept' and has been drawn up by the senior officer in charge of the special forces, the Director Special Forces (DSF).

The new missions would take UKSF units in a less "kinetic" or violent direction and into closer cooperation with allied intelligence agencies and MI6.

There are three main elements of the UK's Special Forces: the regular Special Air Service regiment (22 SAS), the Special Boat Service (SBS), and Special Reconnaissance Regiment (SRR).

The role of the SRR, which carried out covert surveillance, would grow under the Special Operations Concept – stated in the BBC’s report

7 Feb 2022 - UK sends more than 100 SAS and SBS special boat services forces advisors to Kiev as more than 1,000 elite US troops arrive in Poland'

The UK has sent more than 100 special forces advisors to Kiev to train Ukrainian soldiers as tensions reach boiling point over fears of a Russian invasion. 

8 Feb 2022 - EXU-1, FBI Host Maritime Post-Blast Investigation Course at NAS Key West   

14 Feb 2022 -  Russia using Nord Stream 2 as ‘geopolitical weapon’, Zelensky warns Germany’s Scholz

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky on Monday told Germany’s visiting Chancellor Olaf Scholz that Russia was wielding its Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline as a “geopolitical weapon”. 

US President Joe Biden has warned that he would find a way to “bring an end” to the project should Russia invade Ukraine. 

[M: Again, Biden speaks about Nord Stream 2, not both projects. The breakdown of data about US involvement in the affair is in a separate post here]

[M: UK government official´s statements post summer 2021 are listed here] 

II. In the war 

March 2022 - Geopolitical implications of Nord Stream 2 - UK Parliament

Implications for Ukraine - Nord Stream 2 has implications for Ukraine. Although not a huge importer of Russian gas, Ukraine is a major transit country of current Russian gas pipelines into Europe. Transit fees are thought to account for almost 3% of Ukraine’s GDP, which will bring an expected revenue of $2-3 billion annually over the next five years.

Loss of revenue to Ukraine

Gazprom transportation projects to Europe

Two main critics objections

 

[M: The Nordstream AG (1,2) are the only private RU pipelines incorporated in Switzerland. Yamal through Belarus is sanctioned by Poland, one out of two pipelines through Ukraine is also closed by Ukraine which leaves only the 1 pipeline to NW Europe. TurkStream is serving more southern European markets. If Nordstream is taken down gas must flow through Ukraine. Interesting that such information about how much Ukraine gets in fees is on UK government web.] 

28 March 2022 Zelensky ranks which countries are helping Ukraine most as he praises Boris Johnson but rebukes Macron

5 May 2022 - A very strange message to Boris Johnson and V. Zelenski appeared o Twitter:


17 June 2022 - UK PM makes second trip to Kyiv — as it happened

22 July 2022 - Ukrainian Navy training in Britain

 


17 July 2022 - Boris Johnson gives Churchill award to Ukraine's Zelenskyy

20 July 2022 - International partners of Ukraine in the G7 and Paris Club announce suspension of debt service payments for Ukraine

On July 20, a group of creditors of Ukraine from G7 countries and Paris club members (the “Group of Creditors”) announced their intention to suspend principal and interest payments on bilateral debts from 1 August 2022 until the end of the year 2023, with the possibility to extend the suspension by an additional year.

25 July 2022 - Meet Elite British Commandos – The SBS – That ‘Helped’ Ukraine To Snatch Back Snake Island From Russia

According to reports, the Royal Navy’s Special Boat Service taught the troops how to operate underwater vehicles. The vehicles, often called sea scooters or diver propulsion devices, are made to carry frogmen from a combat swimmer unit or naval Special Forces over great distances underwater.

Diver Propulsion Vehicles are helpful for long journeys at a constant depth where navigation is easy. It allows the delivery of combat divers and their equipment over distances or at speeds that would be otherwise impracticable.

It has been revealed that the Special Boat Service from Dorset traveled to the conflict-torn Ukraine to instruct the 73rd Naval Special Purpose Center there.

According to a Sunday Mirror report, the 73rd became the sword’s tip and provided the fighting force that landed on the island. “The Ukrainian special forces are as fierce as they come, but they lack our specialized equipment and instruction,” the report said.

According to British media reports, the Ukrainian combat divers surveyed the coastline for explosives with assistance from the British Navy before signaling for the main force to attack the Russian position.

The United Kingdom has undoubtedly been one of the most ardent supporters of Ukraine, supplying military and non-military aid in billions of dollars. However, the role of its Special Boat Service (SBS), now in the limelight, has proved to be the most decisive for Ukraine yet fatal for the Russians. 

27 August 2022 - The UK drones for Ukraine 

 

3 Sept 2022 - Zelensky exclusive: Threat from ‘Putin the Nazi’ outweighs pain of rising energy bills

The Ukrainian leader praises Boris Johnson, criticises Macron and Scholz and says western cost of living fears are ‘incomparable’ with the threat from Russia.

Volodymyr Zelensky refuses to talk about Boris Johnson in the past tense.

Under Johnson, Britain was one of the first nations to donate weapons to Ukraine as the countdown to the Russian invasion began last winter. While nervous European leaders dawdled, Johnson led the pack..

[M: Compare these sparse comments against UK rhetoric, policies and strategies against Nordstream 1, 2 and all Russian hydrocarbons - Post here]

 

III. Did Zelenski know something about attack on Nordstream? 

4 Sept 2022 - Zelenskiy Tells Europe To Prepare For Difficult Winter With Oil, Gas Supply Cuts

4 Sept 2022 - Zelenski warns that Russia is preparing a «decisive blow» in its energy offensive against Europe

Instead of tanks and missiles, Russia is using energy as a weapon, he said, and is preparing a "decisive blow" in the energy sector this winter.

Russia switches off Europe’s main gas pipeline until sanctions are lifted

Russia’s gas supplies to Europe via the Nord Stream 1 pipeline will not resume in full until the “collective west” lifts sanctions against Moscow over its invasion of Ukraine, the Kremlin has said.

Josep Borrell, the EU’s chief diplomat, on Monday acknowledged that certain political factions in the bloc wanted the EU to drop its support for Ukraine, push Kyiv into a ceasefire and abandon sanctions against Russia to ease economic pressure on European countries. He said those views were “not representative” of the position adopted by member states.

 [...M: Is it possible that Germany wanted to restart the Nordstream? Post here]

7 Sept 2022 - I spoke to President @ZelenskyyUa this evening and...

... reiterated our steadfast support for Ukraine’s freedom and democracy. Russia's attempts to weaponise energy must not deter the West. Ukraine can depend on the UK for support in the long term

 

[M: The post about Liz Truss during her region as UK Prime Minister is here]

 

NEWS

13 Sep 2022 - Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has met in Kyiv with Defense Ministers Morten Bodskov of Denmark and Hanno Pevkur of Estonia.

13 Sep 2022 - Denmark says it will host training of Ukrainian soldiers

COPENHAGEN: Denmark has agreed to train Ukrainian soldiers on Danish soil, Ritzau news agency quoted Defence Minister Morten Bodskov as saying after a meeting with his Ukrainian counterpart in Kyiv on Tuesday. 

14 Sep 2022 - Anders Fogh Rasmussen 

Yesterday, I was in Kyiv to present recommendations on security guarantees to President @ZelenskyyUa. Ukraine is showing that with the necessary resources, it is more than a match for Russia on the battlefield. Now Ukraine's allies must step up for the long-term. 

14 Sep 2022 - Statement by Group of Creditors of Ukraine 

Finally, the Group strongly encourages all other official bilateral creditors to swiftly reach

agreement with Ukraine on a debt service suspension.

We will continue to closely coordinate and assess the situation with the support of the IMF and the World Bank.

Background note: The Group of Creditors of Ukraine includes Canada, France, Germany, Japan, United Kingdom, and the United States of America. Observers to the Group include Australia, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Denmark, Finland, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Korea, the Netherlands, Norway, Spain, Sweden, and Switzerland. 

Ukraine has accepted Denmark's offer to train Ukrainian soldiers on Danish soil. The Minister of Defence of Denmark, Morten Bødskov, announced this during his visit to Kyiv 

19 Sep 2022 - President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelenskyy held a meeting with Minister of Defense of Denmark Morten Bødskov and Minister of Defense of Estonia Hanno Pevkur. 

19 Sep 2022 - Minister of Defence of Ukraine Oleksii Reznikov met with Minister of Defence of Denmark Morten Bødskov who headed the Danish delegation on a visit to Kyiv.  

IV. United Nations General Assembly  

20 Sep 2022 - Liz Truss lands in US to reset ‘special relationship’ on first foreign trip as PM

“My message to the people of Ukraine is this: the UK will continue to be right behind you every step of the way. Your security is our security.”

She will also tell fellow leaders that they must put an end to Putin’s economic blackmail by removing all energy dependence on Russia. 

“Too many lives – in Ukraine, in Europe and around the world – are being manipulated by a dependence on Russian energy. We need to work together to end this once and for all.” 

21 Sept 2022 - UK Prime Minister Truss addresses the United Nations General Assembly (transcript here)


01:00 min: "...Geopolitics is entering a new era.."

06:00 min: "We are cutting off the toxic power and pipelines from authoritarian regimes and strengthening our energy resilience."

"We will ensure we cannot be coerced or harmed by the reckless actions of rogue actors abroad."

"The free world needs this economic strength and resilience to push back against authoritarian aggression and win this new era of strategic competition.

We must do this together."

We are fortifying our deep security alliances in Europe and beyond through NATO and the Joint Expeditionary Force.

08:30 min: "The UK is providing funding, using the might of the City of London and our security capabilities to provide better alternatives to those offered by malign regimes.
The resolute international response to Ukraine has shown how we can deliver decisive collective action. 

22 Sept 2022 -  Speech by the President of Ukraine at the General Debate of the 77th session of the UN General Assembly 

[M: there is barely much about the RU energy, compare to Liz Truss cancelling pipelines of authoritarian regimes] 

22 Sept 2022 - Zelensky meets with European Commission head in New York

President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky met with President of the European Commission Ursula von der Leyen in New York, and stressed the importance of strategic dialogue on energy security. 

“I thanked von der Leyen for the participation of the EU in the Crimea Platform Summit at the highest level & the allocation of a macro-financial aid tranche. Discussed preparations for the Ukraine-EU Summit on Oct 12. Stressed the importance of strategic dialogue on the EU energy security,” Zelensky wrote on Twitter. 

[M: The more interesting happening around Liz Truss and her statements is in a separate posts here and here and here

26 Sept 2022 - Time Magazine Dedicated Its Cover And Article To Valeriy Zaluzhny
 

 

V. From Nordstream affair onward

27 Sept 2022 - Denmark, Sweden view Nord Stream leaks as 'sabotage'

Ukraine has put the blame firmly at the door of Russia.

"The large-scale 'gas leak' from Nord Stream 1 is nothing more than a terrorist attack planned by Russia and an act of aggression towards the EU," Kyiv's presidential advisor Mikhaylo Podolyak wrote on Twitter.

[M: There are two groups here, one who claims and defines it is "sabotage" and the other as "lets see, what investigation shows", Russia claims Terrorist act. Ukraine blaming terrorist act is a hint they did not know likely who was behind.]  

27 Sept 2022 - UkrainePodolyakGas Leaks on Nord Stream 1 Pipeline is Russia’s Terrorist Attac

“ ‘Gas leak’ from NS-1 is nothing more that a terrorist attack planned by Russia and an act of aggression towards EU. Russia wants to destabilize economic situation in Europe and cause pre-winter panic. The best response and security investment – tanks for Ukraine. Especially German ones…,” Podolyak wrote. 

[M: The Ukrainian statement that it is a Russian terrorist act is in contradiction to EU sabotage framing. This "kind of" excludes Ukraine as a suspect. /deductive-logical.]  

27 Sept 2022 - NATO Secretary General at EU Parliament: stay the course on Ukraine

[M: The post about who tried to frame the affair as a "sabotage" aand changed the perception from a more serious classification of "armored attack / terrorist act" is here. Note that Ukraine tried first to have similar "more harsh" classification as "terrorist act" but later changed it to be along Europeand and USA view to just a  "sabotage". Important post about this phenomena is here and here]


VI. The Bridge

8 Oct 2022 - From Portsmouth to Odesa, UK and Ukraine naval cooperation on show as Ukrainian President visits HMS Prince of Wales

Defence Secretary Ben Wallace was able to showcase the awesome capabilities of UK defence whilst hosting Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Defence Minister Andriy Taran aboard HMS Prince of Wales, docked at Her Majesty’s Naval Base Portsmouth

It came as Royal Navy Type 45 destroyer HMS Dragon sails in the Black Sea in support of freedom of navigation. A port visit to Odesa will enable interactions with Ukrainian counterparts and showcase the UK-led Maritime Training Initiative.

8 Oct 2022 - Crimean Bridge explosion

On 8 October 2022, at 6:07 am, a fire broke out on the Crimean Bridge as a result of an explosion, which occurred on the road bridge, on or under the westbound vehicle lanes running from Russia to Kerch in occupied Crimea. Two two-lane vehicular spans of the bridge collapsed into the water. Two adjacent eastbound lanes on independent structure survived. The railway bridge was also significantly damaged by fire on railway tanker cars. Four people were killed.

 

VII. Afterwards

21 Jan 2023 - Volodymyr Zelenskyy met with Boris Johnson

23 Jan 2023 - Volodymyr Zelensky Says It Would Be A 'Pleasure' If Boris Johnson Was Amabassador To Ukraine

"He is a good guy," the Ukrainian president said.

His comments, in an interview with Sky News, came just days after Johnson made a surprise visit to Kyiv. 

25 Jan 2023 - Boris Johnson visits Kyiv, pledges help

26 Jan 2023 - Volodymyr Zelensky Says It Would Be A 'Pleasure' If Boris Johnson Was Ambassador To Ukraine

[M: In another news, the destruction of Nordstream forces Russia to use Ukrainian pipeline so Ukraine will get transfer fees which make some 3% of UA GDP according to UK study]

23 May 2022 - In Dallas, former British Prime Minister Boris Johnson calls for Ukraine support

‘I’m here to say thanks, but also stick with it,’ Johnson said during a stop at The Dallas Morning News’ editorial board.


VIII. Two insurance exclusion caluses 

When the case is defined as a self-sabotage (Russia was behind the Nordstream) or an act of war (Ukraine was behind the Nordstream) then the insurance claim is not possible.

[M: More about the insurance in a separate post here]

IX. Anglo Saxons... -> see here

- still a d r a f t post -
I work on the investigation almost every day last 7-8 months,..
adding data, updating,.. not much editing, style, focusing on content.
Here is another new post, 2nd today, tomorrow I continue...

...future posts, roadmap:

- Data about BoJO, similar to Liz Truss post
- Data about UK changes in several important posts in Navy
- Post about when the decision was most likely made
- Improvement of the pre 2021 Nordstream opposition post
- Insurance revisited
- Collection of statements by SWE, DK, GER investigators
- fixes of old posts, styles, formatting, etc
- revisiting main timeline and crossreffiling posts with new data scattered in other posts


Summary...

17 March 2023 - Debt service suspension for Ukraine extended until 2027

At a virtual meeting held on 14 September 2022, Germany joined other official bilateral creditors and the government of Ukraine in concluding a Memorandum of Understanding to provide coordinated debt service suspension for Ukraine. Under the Memorandum, Ukraine’s payment obligations will be suspended until the end of 2023. On 24 March 2023, the Group of Creditors extended the existing debt service suspension until 2027. In addition, the Group will carry out a comprehensive debt restructuring in order to restore Ukraine’s debt sustainability. These steps are preconditions for an IMF programme, which Germany is advocating.

23 June 2023 - Supranational Exposure to Ukraine Is Growing

Fitch Ratings downgraded Ukraine’s Long-Term Foreign-Currency (LT FC) Issuer Default Rating (IDR) to ‘RD’ (restricted default) in August 2022, due to a two-year deferral on Eurobond payments, which constitutes a distressed debt exchange (DDE). Since the completion of the DDE, which cured the default, Fitch has upgraded and maintained the LT FC IDR at ‘CC’, reflecting the probability of further restructuring of both official bilateral and commercial debt. Recent developments are consistent with this view, most notably the IMF analysis underpinning the four-year Extended Fund Facility (EFF) approved at end-March 2023. The analysis incorporates the Group of Creditors for Ukraine (GCU) commitment to a three-year extension to end-2026 of the standstill on official sector payments, and signalled intent of the Ukrainian authorities to seek comparability of treatment with commercial debt.

056 - Anchoring near Nordstream pipelines

 PREFACE/ISSUE

This short post looks at the maritime law covering anchoring in the vicinity of pipelines which have some 200m protection no anchoring zone.

Fatboy Slim ft. Bootsy Collins - Weapon Of Choice


I. Danish Building permit - prohibited areas established

Danish Maritime Authority allows construction of Nordtsream 2 AG pipelines section in Danish TZ:



II. Law forbids anchoring nearby pipelines, criminal liability for damages

Order no. 939 of 27 November 1992 on the protection of submarine cables and submarine pipelines(the Cable Order)

Pursuant to Section 5(4) and Section 6(3) of the Act on Safety of Navigation, cf. Consolidated Act no. 587 of 29 September 1988, and by authority given in Order no. 570 of 26 September 1988, the following provisions are laid down after consultation with the Danish Ministry of Defence and the Danish Ministry of Transport, cf. Act no. 54 of 15 February 1895 on the protection of submarine cables and submarine pipelines, as amended by Act no. 134 of 10 May 1915, Act no. 151 of 10 May 1967 and Act no. 480 of 8 November 1972:

Section 1. Ships may not, without urgent necessity, anchor in the cable and pipeline fields laid down for submarine cables and submarine pipelines of any type (pipelines for the carriage of hydrocarbons, etc.), which cover the associated protective zones, cf. Section 4. 

[M: the protection zone is 200m around cables, pipelines] 

Annex Submarine cables and submarine pipelines 

1 General 

"Persons who cause damage to pipelines shall be criminally liable
and possibly liable to pay damages according to the circumstances."


III. Russia was scanning for anchor marks shortly after

27 Oct 2022 - Erik Andersson: This Sunday afternoon Oct 3 Russian ship Nefrit..

..scans an area about 1km wide with the Nordstream 1 rupture in the middle. (screenshot from Marine Traffic web site)

The Russian unit does not need to apply for permission from Stockholm to conduct its own operations.

The pipeline operator, Nord Stream AG, said in a statement that the vessel would begin surveying the pipeline damage area within 24 hours. He will spend three to five days there. 

[M: Could recent anchor marks be still visible to very sensitive equipment? Would it find divers equipment? What is search diameter?] 

 

IV. Russian A2AD (Anti access Area Denial system)

Anti-Access Area Denial systems and radars from RU enclave can see much. They can see very much what is on the surface and could send there in a no time a plane to have a look would a suspicious boat spend too long time over its pipelines. 

 


Additionally this post explores that submarine or minisubmarine was the delivery system which brought the divers and explosives to the site:

Whose submarine visited Bornholm Deep before the Nordstream was blown up?


V. The importance of Exclusive Economic Zone Teritorial Zones (TZ)

According to UNCLOS (United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea), coastal states have sovereign rights over their EEZs, which includes the exclusive right to authorize, regulate and control any activities related to the exploration, exploitation, conservation, and management of the natural resources within their EEZs.

         The Big picture of whole Baltic Sea (EEZs)


Therefore, any investigation within the EEZ must be carried out with the consent and cooperation of state which owns the EEZ. Failure to seek consent may result in a violation of state B's sovereignty and may be considered a breach of international law.

 

VI. The location is everything

The choice has been made to target selected locations in both:
 Danish EEZ, Swedish EEZ but not in Danish TZ.

Subsequently both states investigate hits on both pipelines.

Therefore two investigations (SWE, DK) are taking place.



[M: Note the closeness to the bubble around Bornholm = Danish TZ.]

 

VII. Russia can not patrol Nordstream in Territorial waters  

The free passage law allows ships to pass freely but forbids military vessels to conduct naval operations. This includes anti submarine search.

In May 2022 Boris Johnson received very odd Twitter tweet,
it stated the vulnerability of NS in terms of location
and legal issues due to its HQ/incorporation in Switzerland.

See 

Last 5 (3up, 2 down) pictures via Billy Bostickson @BillyBostickson´s post


VIII. Russians monitoring its assets in Danish Territorial waters

1 May 2022 - Denmark, Sweden summon Russian ambassadors over spy plane flight 

Authorities from both Denmark and Sweden reported that the Russian plane entered Danish airspace on Friday evening east of the Danish Baltic island of Bornholm then entered Swedish airspace.
 
16 June 2022 - Russian Ambassador Summoned Following Violation of Danish Airspace: “Inacceptable breach”

The summons is a reaction to Russia’s violation of Danish airspace on 11 June between 11:08 a.m. and 11:42 a.m., during which time two Russian SU-30 fighter planes were observed over Danish airspace near Christiansø Island and Bornholm Island.

[M: Note that this is about the time of Baltops AND yearly maintenance. Posts are here and here. Something was spotted on 14th of June 2022 around the future location of blasts. RU ship turned and went to explore the place. Later more RU assets were called in.] 

17 June 2022 - Russian warship violated Danish territorial waters in Baltic, Danish military says

[M: Note that some ASW search action was also done by US helicopters. Was this the reason why USA warned the Germany and allies about the strategic threat and possibility of future attacks against pipelines?] 

1 Sept 2022 - Russian Ambassador Summoned To Denmark After Alleged Airspace Violation 


IX. Seems USA was also monitoring pipeline locations

5 - 17 June 2022 - BALTOPS 22 KICKS OFF IN THE BALTIC SEA

June 8 2022, the Boeing P-8A simply switched off its call signseveral rounds over the NS blast site. 

Joachim Wagner, @WagnerJoac 

1,2,3 Sept 2022 - US Military Helicopters Circled Around Future Nord Stream Leaks For Hours In September 

 

[M: Again those helicopters from Kaersarge group seem to be searching for something under. Note info on the post 1-3/09/2022 here]  [M: Note that helicopters are excellent for ASW,

Anti-Submarine-Warfare, they stay at place,
they can drop sonar or sonar-buoy and transmit data]

[M: Looks like a chase but there was no boat there]

[M: Again, ASW capability.
Helicopters are better than planes due to lower speed for anti-sub warfare]

FlightRadar shows a few flights there on that day

[M: There were several flight and several investigations, was this just a drill?]


[M: The post of the blogger is interesting. How so no Russian sub was announced?
US was conducting anti-submarine mission which has not been a drill.]
[Could it be that a UK submarine was discovered here?]
 
It is curious that on September 2, almost in parallel with the US military, a military helicopter NH90 of the Dutch Navy was flying in the vicinity of Bornholm Island, probably observing the activities of the Americans....



US helicopters, according to Flightradar24, also flew over the branches of Russian gas pipelines on September 10 and September 19.

[Could it be that a UK submarine was tracked and followed here?]

In all cases, the trajectories of the US military speak of observation flights or loitering with other targets over a specific section of the water area. Helicopters that made sorties on the night of September 22-23 and 25-26 have especially confusing tracks.

 


 [M: Perhaps there was a UK submarine in the vicinity and US Navy from Kaersarge was tracking its movements. This kind of excludes that it was a secret approved NATO operation, looks more like UK went rogue and USA has been on it, knew, monitored yet has not stopped it or did not understand intentions of the submarine - speculating on another post with How it maybe went - so far sequence is in few posts on twitter. Btw, the path looks like the helicopter dropped sonarbuoys, then cycles to transmit its data to Kaersarge]. 

 

2 Sept 2022 - helicopter call sign FFAB123 MH-60S from USS Kearsarge flew either along the route of Nord Stream-2 or generally between the points where the accident occurred.

 

X. The knowledge about laws covering subsea cables and pipelines

Rishi Sunak is most likely the only high government official who had a deep knowledge about implications of critical infrastructure in EEZs.

Rishi Sunak´s 2017 report about vulnerability of subsea internet cables

The Definition, Severity and Accountability of the Nordstream Affair

 

XI. The Bornholm Deep is ideal for submarine operations

These posts explore the submarine/mini-submarine approach:

20 points about UK submarines, DDS, SWCS, MK11, deep divers, DTXG team



Conclusion:

  • Big ships would be seen on radara.

  • Small ships would leave anchor trace

  • Submarines could hide in Danish Territorial zone lowering risk of being exposed by Russians or allies. TZ offers protection

  • Bornholm Deep basin is ideal for submarine operations